x
x
x
Hearts Hearts Hearts Hearts 5 5 5 5
Si l’ennemi ne traite pas ses prisonniers de guerre conformément au droit international, que devez-vous faire?
Qu’est-ce que vous en pensez?  Les Conventions de Genève protègent les droits des prisonniers de guerre. Nous respectons les règles parce que c’est la bonne chose à faire indépendamment de ce que fait l’ennemi.

‘Abiding by the conventions [on the treatment of prisoners of war’ is desirable if for no other reason than to protect one’s nationals who are the others’ prisoners. [Mistreatment] can also result in war crimes accusations later when the conflict has ended. So, at least for reasons of reciprocity and fear of punitive consequences states may comply with these international standards.’ (Sawicki 2015).

Prisoners of war are protected under International Law and must not be harmed. The enemy might deliberately try to manipulate us into breaching these laws and violate common decency and morality. One of the reasons we fight is to uphold these laws and standards of decency, and to descend to the same level as the enemy would undermine the reasons behind the war.

'Dealign with prisoners of war is a military requirement ad the cost in terms of resources - including manpower and equipment - must be included in the commander's planning for operations.' (McEvoy 2011)

John Sawicki, CSSP, ‘Treatment of Prisoners and Detainees’ in James Turner Johnson and Eric D. Patterson (eds.), The Ashgate Research Companion to Military Ethics, (Ashgate, Farnham, 2015), p271.

Philip McEvoy, ‘Law at the Operational Level’ in David Whetham (ed.), Ethics, Law and Military Operations, (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, 2011), pp124-125.

x
x